Complications of
unsafe abortions are a major public health issue facing women of
reproductive age in developing countries like India. Inducedabortions
have been practised to varying degrees in all cultures by women
facing unwanted pregnancies as a result of high level of unmet need
for good quality family planning services. Safe, effective and affordable
technologies to prevent unwanted pregnancies and to treat complications
of abortions do exist, yet a large number of women in need are still
deprived of the benefit of these technologies.
In India, an estimated 453 women die due to maternal causes for
every 100,000 live births (UNFPA 1997). An average of 12 to 18%
of maternal deaths result from unsafe abortion practices (Registrar
General of India, 1996). Each abortion-related mortality represents
manifold morbidity ranging from incomplete abortion, haemorrhage,
cervical injury, uterine perforation, pelvic infection and infertility.
Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) has a network of Human
Reproduction Research Centres(HRRCs), created with the objectives
to undertake clinical trials of new technologies, to carry out programme
introduction studies with new technologies and to undertake operational
research for improving health-care delivery and utilisation of RCH
services
Figure
5.1.1 – ICMR’s network of HRRCs |
Studies conducted on medical methods of termination of early pregnancy
by ICMR are as follows:
(1) Phase II clinical trial with RU-486 alone or in combination
with oral 9-methylene–PGE2 (meteneprost) for termination of
early pregnancy within 49 days of amenorrhoea. (1987 - 89) (unpublished).
The success rate ranged between 47% – 69% with four different
treatment regimens. The data suggests that the addition of 9-methylene-PGE2
administered in the present form, orally does not increase the success
rate.
(2) A multicentric clinical trial with RU-486 followed by 9-methylene
PGE2 vaginal gel for termination of early pregnancy: Dose-finding
study (1990-92) (Contraception 1994; 49: 87-98). A dose finding
study was carried out with two different doses of RU486 (200 mg
or 600 mg) each in combination with two different doses of 9-methylene-PGE2
vaginal gel (3mg or 5 mg) for termination of pregnancy between 7
and 28 days after missed menstrual period. It was observed that
success rates with 200 mg RU486 followed by 3 mg and 5 mg 9- methylene-PGE2
vaginal gel were 94.5% and 89.6% in women with 7 to 14 days and
15 to 28 days of missed menstrual period respectively. These rates
were similar to those observed with 600 mg RU486 given along with
3 mg or 5 mg or 9- methylene-PGE2 vaginal gel and were significantly
higher than those observed with 200 mg RU486 given along with 3
mg 9-methylene-PGE2 vaginal gel. The average duration of bleeding
in subjectswith complete abortion ranged between 7 and 11.8 days
in 4 different schedules. There were no serious side-effects with
any of the treatment schedules; only one subject required transfusion
of one unit of blood for heavy bleeding. The immediate and delayed
complication rates were similar with the four treatment schedules.
(3) A multicentric randomised comparative clinical trial of 200
mg RU-486 (mifepristone) single dose followed by either 5 mg 9-methylene
PGE2 gel (meteneprost) or 600 µg oral PGE1 (misoprostol) for
termination of early pregnancy within 28 days of missed menstrual
period (1996). The study enrolled 907 women in 10 HRRCs, of these
9 were excluded due to protocol violations and 5 were lost to followup.
The results of 893 subjects indicated a succes rate of 84.6% among
453 women treated with RU 486 and meteneprost that was not significantly
different from the success rate of 87.7% observed in 440 women treated
with RU486 and oral misoprostol. Most (90%) women started bleeding
within 72 hours and about 26% even before the administration of
any prostaglandin. Expulsion was reported in 7% of women before
prostaglandin administration. There was no statistically significant
difference between the two groups. The average duration of bleeding
in all subjects was about 7 days. No life threatening side-effects
were observed. Gastrointestinal side-effects were reported more
often by women treated with oral PGE1 as compared to 9-methylene-PGE2
gel. Six subjects in each of the treatment groups required intravenous
infusion of glucose and saline. Blood transfusion was required in
2 subjects, one in each treatment group, for profuse bleeding. (Contraception
2000; 62: 125-30)
(4) ICMR along with MOHFW has also started a study in 20 district
hospitals to study the acceptability, efficacy and logistic requirement
for medical method of termination of pregnancy in the existing clinical
setting.To conclude, RU-486 (200 mg) orally followed by 600 µg
of oral misoprostol for termination of early pregnancy is a better
option because of ease of treatment administration. Back-up facilities
for surgical evacuation and blood transfusion are essential.
Criteria for assessing the treatment outcomes for medical
abortion :
Assessment of outcome is done on day 15 of RU- 486 administration.
Successful Outcome The outcome
is considered successful when the criteria fulfilled are: history
of onset of bleeding per vaginum, history of expulsion of products/clots,
decrease of uterine size to non-pregnant level, negative urine pregnancy
test and no additional intervention required to complete the process
of pregnancy termination.
Unsuccessful Outcome
Incomplete abortion: The outcome of treatment
is considered as incomplete abortion in subjects who start bleeding
but their uterine size remains bulky, on followup, irrespective
of the fact whether the urine pregnancy test is positive or negative,
or if additional surgical intervention is required to complete the
process of evacuation of the products of conception.
Continuation of pregnancy : The
outcome of treatment is considered as continuation of pregnancy
if the uterine size increases from pretreatment condition and urine
pregnancy test remains positive at follow-up even though vaginal
bleeding may or may not have occurred.
Trial interruption : The outcome
of treatment is also considered as unsuccessful when pregnancy has
to be interrupted surgically before follow-up either due to medical
reasons such as profuse bleeding or symptoms like severe abdominal
pain or due to any other reason.
|